Following up on Joe’s good post yesterday about healthcare, I had my ACA call with my insurance agent yesterday. It was grim. The plan that I have this year went up to over $2,000/month. I was paying under $500 with the subsidy. We found another plan that’s about $1,800 a month, and if either I or my wife gets seriously ill, we’ll be on the hook for upwards of $30,000 before we get any real help from the insurance company.

Don’t worry about us, we’re fine. We’re savers and the only reason either of us are working is to make our nut before Social Security and Medicare kick in, plus we both have work we like. Obviously, the insurance companies looked at what the Republicans are doing and decided, “welp, whatever happens, we’re pricing these plans so that we’re not on the hook for their stupidity.”

Frankly, I’ve been wondering why we even work. If we made $0, we’d actually be eligible for a subsidy. One of the many ironies of the American Calvinist welfare system, a patchwork of means-tested idiocy, is that it ultimately incentivizes “cheating”.

The other part of the horrible experience I had yesterday is that the Colorado exchange gave me a “choice” of like 93 different policies, each with slightly different terms. It was all fuckery. They’re bad insurance, but each of them is bad in their own, special little way. As Joe pointed out, we’re better off today with the ACA than the alternative, but it’s all a band-aid on an arterial bleed. The ACA did very little to rein in the cost of healthcare, and the complexity of the thing is what happens when insurance companies win. If the Democrats who wanted a public option would have won, I’m sure we’d all be on it by now.

Another follow-up on yesterday’s Mexico post: Today is the anniversary of yet another Mexican independence, Revolution Day. Like all the other Mexican independence days, it’s a big deal, because Mexicans love a party. Anyway, the “Gen Z” astroturf movement that I wrote about yesterday is threatening to disrupt the Revolution Day gathering in the Zócalo, the square in front of the National Palace. Yesterday, T Bone posted a link to a leftist English-language Mexican politics site called Mexico Solidarity Media, and they have a podcast called Soberanía (“soverignty”). In the most recent episode of that podcast, they put the Gen Z protest in the context of the US desire to create a false crisis in Mexico so Trump can have an excuse to invade or at minimum fuck with Mexico.

Well, if you’re inclined to believe that, which I am, one little piece of evidence is the State Department’s STEP messages, which are alerts for travelers. Yesterday, they sent out a warning about today’s protest. They sent nothing about Saturday’s protest that turned violent. It will be interesting to see if this protest amounts to anything. Unlike Saturday’s event, this one will mix people there to celebrate Mexico with a bunch of right wing haters.

In related Mexico news, the head of the Morena party posted that one of the organizers of the Gen Z protests is on the payroll of opposition party PAN to the tune of $114,800/year. The median yearly income in Mexico was a little under $20,000 in 2023.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

The CO ACA exchange sucks. I've compared stories from here, like yours, to other places where the exchange is considered top notch, like ME.

Like I said yesterday "choice" has become a 4-letter-word in my vocabulary. So yeah, how did 90+ "choices" help you? Not. One. Damned. Bit.

And of course the ACA did nothing to reign in the cost of health care.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Choices have to be meaningful, and some of the work David Anderson at Balloon Juice was doing was making sure choices are meaningful. There were spamming strategies that he was calling out.

A selection is fine, a large variety of things that are crappy in various ways leads to analysis paralysis.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I'm wondering if Mexicans will react differently to the right wing thugs during protests than we do here. We'll see ...

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Reposting this propaganda from yesterday.

Rep. Carlos Gimenez makes a case that Mexican cartels are worse than al Qaeda and hence a valid target for US military strikes (video):

https://bsky.app/profile/atrupar.com/post/3m5z7isozfh2q

I miss Stonekettle - he authored an article about the War on Drugs that was so spot on. I'll see if I can find it.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

If I had six months to read & parse the fine print on all the different "choices" (complications) presented on The Exchange website, I would STILL choose by throwing a dart at my computer screen.

As it happened, our state Exchange never contacted me after I wasted hours on hold on phone, sent emails through the portal explaining, and attempted to correct my income info online like six times. BC/BS unilaterally issued a new policy with new premium payments due based on that erroneous info, so I called them in response. Their rep connected my call to The Exchange which picked up the phone immediately since it appeared it was coming from the insurance company. Now I have the same crappy coverage (I hope) but it's still free. That's about what it is worth (zero) but at least if something catastrophic happens I'll have someone to fight with about paying.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Moral of the story: the Exchange is just another insane insurance racket. The insurance companies want that money and will get it from either the government or the rubes no matter what.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

One of the things I said back during the health care debate was that while in the abstract I didn't have anything against providing universal health insurance through a regulated market instead of a government program, in the real world context that is the United States of America in 2010, I don't for one second trust the corporate environment we're talking about. It's as absurd as imposing regulations on crime syndicates: every single thing they do is going to be done in bad faith, every single action they take is going to be taken with an eye to skirting the law as closely as possible, every single waking moment is going to be spent trying to figure out how to avoid the law, flout the spirit of the law, or straight up find whatever ways they can to break the law. At a certain point, if you're watching the insurance companies as closely as you're going to have to for this to even have a prayer of making the system work, why not just provide the health care yourself?

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I basically try to do that because the system failed me so badly with long Lyme and long Covid. I'm gaslit everywhere I go, even, and especially, the dentists here are mostly just ripoff artists.

Had a cavity filled yesterday and had to listen to her bitch about Bad Bunny ruining the Super Bowl 🙄

I try like hell to self treat with ice, heat, saline, extra fiber, homemade Jewish penicillin, etc. etc. before I seek "professional" care.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

One rheumatologist specialist here diagnosed me with Gulf War Syndrome! A "top doc" in his field .

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

It's a criminal racketeering syndicate, no doubt about it!

Avatar

C P1 year ago

I'll always remember the person who, when I told her I had given her the paperwork proving that X operation was in-network, literally just went "oh, well, if it's physical and not email, we might not have it. You know, a lot of paperwork just... goes missing here." It's literally as unsubtle as the mob leg-breaker going "whaddaya mean? Of course you didn't give me this week's protection money yesterday. If you had, would I be here today?" (And yeah, it did teach me never to hand over paperwork without making a copy first).

What made Leverage great was the understanding that in the twenty-first century, the kind of mob bosses that the A-Team used to beat up every week in the eighties have largely been replaced by the corrupt bankers or insurers that fucked us so badly in 2008. It's a great successor to the kind of shows John Rogers used to watch when he was young, because it actually bothers to update the context in a way that straight remakes mostly don't.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Mamdani is going to the White House. I predict we get Medicare for All.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

😆

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

All he needs is a poster board with some flattering depiction of Trump and we’re good to go!