❝

More than 150 Michigan pastors endorsed Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan on Monday in his bid to become the state's next governor, calling him a leader who has the capacity "to bring people together."

Duggan, who is running as an independent, shared the sanctuary space with more than two dozen pastors at Straight Gate International Church, 10100 Grand River Avenue in northwest Detroit. A spokeswoman for Duggan's campaign said a "vast majority" of the endorsements are from African American clergy.

Many clergy at Monday's event praised the three-term mayor of Michigan's largest city for tackling such issues as eliminating neighborhood blight, reducing crime and increasing jobs.

He has an extremely pragmatic agenda - 1, 2, and 3.

  1. Keep young people in Michigan

  2. improve public education

  3. make housing affordable


I currently reside and vote in Ohio although we’ve owned property in Michigan for 30 years and plan a residency move to Michigan this summer, so I’ll be voting for Michigan governor next cycle. I’m a Democrat - I actually hold a Democratic leadership post at the county level in Ohio so it is highly unlikely I would vote for Duggan in a three way D, R and I race, but I see the appeal of an Independent bid in the current political climate and think we may be seeing a lot more of this nationally.

There are a lot of Right leaning Democrats in the Great Lakes states - not “Reagan Democrats” or whatever bullshit punditry category media use, but actual voting members of the Democratic Party who are Right leaning. I don’t think one can break this down by race, either. I think there are Right leaning Black Democrats in the Great Lakes states along with Right leaning whites and to a certain extent they feel excluded by college educated liberal Democrats - they see progressive Democrats as joyless scolds who focus on “correct” language rather than results for working people.

As a progressive Democrat on the Left side of the Party I work with these people every day - they make up the majority of the local Democrats in rural Ohio. I do just fine working with them and recognize that my brand of progressive Democrat is probably only 25% of the Party nationwide so I need them if I want to win, and I want to win.

I think you’ll see Right leaning Democrats (or Independents like Duggan) deliberately distance themselves from progressive Democrats not on “issues” - Duggan has been extremely pro immigrant - but on language, like Duggan is doing on immigration:

❝

Tlaib was joined by several immigrant rights activists and Detroit City Councilwoman Gabriela Santiago-Romero in Patton Park, which sits on Vernor Highway, a commercial strip in southwest Detroit packed with small businesses, many of them run by immigrants. The news conference was held on the same day that several immigrant, Latino, Asian American and Black groups released a statement criticizing Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan for using the word "illegal" last week to describe some immigrants. In a statement to the Free Press, Duggan said the attacks on him are a type of "political correctness" and he refused to apologize.

❝

Duggan fired back, saying that in Detroit "we support the success of immigrants. But when Detroit police make a criminal arrest and (the Detroit Police Department) gets federal notification that the person in custody is in the country illegally, we should not and do not shield you from federal enforcement."

Duggan added: "Groups who oppose this position are criticizing me today over the political correctness of my statements, but I do not apologize for providing a clear explanation of Detroit’s position. It is a position we have followed consistently through the Obama, Trump and Biden administrations."

What Duggan said is true - Detroit is (deliberately) not a “sanctuary city” but is instead a “welcoming city” so Detroit has always turned over undocumented people who are charged with a crime and in custody to ICE. Duggan is a three term mayor so actually has consistently applied this policy through Obama, Trump and Biden.

This will be central to his message, I think. The two political parties focus on language - demonizing immigrants on the Right and policing language around immigrants on the Left while he, as a pragmatic centrist, welcomes law abiding immigrants while still prosecuting criminals. This message will be very appealing to Right leaning Democrats of all races and ethnicities, I think. It’s more than “messaging” too. The facts are that both Obama and Biden deported plenty of people - I expect Duggan could truthfully run in a kind of centrist “Obama Lane” on immigration. The Democratic language on immigration is a lot more progressive than the actions of elected Democrats. Progressives have to face that reality.

*Disclosure - Mike Duggan belongs to a large extended family in Michigan who are prominent in legal circles in the state. Duggan’s father was a federal judge. My husband also belongs to this (extended) family on his mother’s side. They all came out of Connecticut originally - a lot of Great Lakes families started in New England and then moved westward.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

After two gubernatorial elections where the Republican won because the Democrat and Independent divided the liberals/progressives, we finally got ranked choice voting via referendum. It has saved us.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

It's funny to see that and then see in NYC how plenty of liberals hate ranked choice and want to do what we do in Denver: jungle primary, 2-person run off.

Which I can attest to sucks massively. So now we're looking at ranked choice as some savior of Democracy. Our glibertarian governor backed a really awful "ranked choice" ballot initiative last fall that was decisively beaten because it really wasn't that; it was simply whoever can throw the most money into an open primary.

Sooooo, many of us don't see ranked choice as some fantastic system per se. It has its own wierdness. Yeah, it's worked for y'all in Maine given recent history there and yes, your governor rocks. But I wonder if that can replicate itself in a "blue" city like Denver where everybody hates the current approach but nobody can agree on a ranked choice approach that doesn't potentially cause equal stupidity.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

You could always copy ours. It works well and it isn’t complicated.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I'll give Duggan this, when he talks about affordable housing, he's actually talking about affordable housing, not the trickle-down, Reaganomics For Housing, market-rate not-at-all-affordable bullshit that big city Dem mayors and clowns like Governor Goodhair II in CA (and plenty of clowns at the other blog) have been spouting for years and the results are, as predicted, the exact opposite of what they were grifting.

Of course since it was all originally sourced by a Thiel-funded astroturf in CA, it's not surprising it's been a lie.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

His housing approach could be copied nationally by Dems. My middle son is buying in Detroit - it’s become popular with the youths 🙂

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I've dug further. In part, he's pushing good ole "tax breaks" as the answer so that market-rate developers can do what they always do if they put aside some non-impactful fraction of new builds for people at the 80% AMI; which is seen by a lot of housing justice people I know as simply a sop to newcoming white professionals, not existing people being displaced.

So in that regard, he's really no different than shitty mayors like mine in Denver other than having a larger fund for it and make it easier to access.

He has refrained from the total de-regulatory agenda that's part and parcel of these same glibertarian housing policies, white urban "Dems" have pushed nonstop on behalf of people like Theil for the last 8 years.

You talk to black/brown people in any metro area and they'll point to Dem-pushed housing policies at the local level (or state level in CA) as a main reason why they're no longer voting for Dems at any level.

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

Duggan has been a good and effective mayor of Detroit, but if he is running as an Independent, he's nothing more than a Republican stooge. I sincerely hope he changes his mind and runs for the Democratic nomination.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Nice to see Rep. Tlaib continues to be utterly useless and performative.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Actually, Rep. Tlaib and her sister were pretty effective at stopping Genocide Joe and Killer Kamala from inflicting further harm on Palestinians. Things are just so much better now without them in power.

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

Word in Michigan has it that the voters in Tlaib's district are not happy with her and are ready to vote her out. I'll believe that when I see it, but it's worth noting.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

The Democratic language on immigration in Colorado always starts with discussing illegal aliens and crime. It buys into the Republican framing of the issue and spends a lot of time there before saying anything positive about any immigrants, even though one of our representatives is first generation American.

Does prosecuting criminals mean handing everyone who shows up to court over to ICE?

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

He said “in custody” - what it means as a practical matter is there won’t be a prosecution on the criminal charge. Instead they’ll be turned over to ICE for deportation (an administrative action, as you know) so Detroit or Michigan won’t have to deal with it at all. In a “sanctuary city” the criminal case would go forward but there would be no ICE involvement.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

In fairness to Duggan too, he really has been very pro immigrant, including Muslim immigrants - important in Michigan. He won his mayors races by a lot. He says right out he’s not a “vision guy” - he’s a manager, and proud of it.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

You see the appeal for cities and states- calling ICE means they don’t have to pay for local adjudication /incarceration on the criminal charge - they just let the feds deport which takes the criminal case off their plate.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

"The Democratic language on immigration is a lot more progressive than the actions of elected Democrats. Progressives have to face that reality."

I think this is part of the reason that Democrats are considered as the party of pretty talk and no -- or in the case the opposite -- action.