Reader J sent me an email yesterday wondering what the Democratic response to Signalgate looks like. (And, look, I hate adding “gate” to any scandal, but when in Rome DC…)

My response was that the Sunday shows were pretty depressing, if you’re a Democrat, because the main character the Democrats sent to them was Sen John Mark Warner. Warner was on three of the big shows and my Sen Michael Bennet was on one of them. Even if you, like me, think the Sunday shows are an anachronism and more-or-less irrelevant, it’s still a big signal from the Democrats that they’re picking a designated spokesman instead of flooding the zone with everyone who knows anything about national security.

Other than that, I’ve heard very little from Democrats recently about a scandal that, if the tables were turned, the Republicans would talk about ad infinitum and ad nauseum.

On yesterday’s Greg Sargent podcast, Jennifer Rubin and Sargent chatted about Signalgate. The discussion referenced this Politico story claiming that Hegseth is in trouble because he’s an unqualified moron (my gloss). Rep Don Bacon (R-NE-2) represented the PVI of his Omaha district (EVEN) by telling the truth, saying that intentionally putting classified information on an unclassified app is the “real crime”. Bacon is a retired Brigadier General in the Air Force, and I’m sure he’s personally disgusted by this whole thing, even though he’s not going to do anything to risk his political career over it.

Apparently some Republicans are going to, maybe, push for an investigation of Signalgate, which I think is the smart political move for them and all other criminals — hide out until the heat is off. While I’m giving Republicans advice, I’d suggest that they use the Merrick Garland strategy of delaying any real consequences for as long as possible. I’ll add some more advice: at the end of this, just make sure that you throw Hegseth under the bus. There are a hundred other morons who are lining up for the job, and Trump is pretty good at finding a scapegoat and firing them.

One of the biggest tells that Trump is losing his grip is that he hasn’t already found a scapegoat and fired that person yet. Trump’s schtick is that he hires people that looked good, but in the end they disappointed him. Apparently, he’s decided that he doesn’t have to bother with that charade anymore.

I guess if the Democrats really wanted to meet the moment, they could have their shadow Defense Secretary have a hearing where experts highlighted the stupidity of using a commercial messaging app to talk about operational details of a military operation, but if I seriously wrote that, I might as well turn this into a blog about unicorns, hobbits, wizards or some other imaginary creatures.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Senator Whitehouse remembered to use a great weapon:

https://bsky.app/profile/whitehouse.senate.gov/post/3llr3u5zhp22o

Avatar

2liberal .1 year ago

"main character the Democrats sent to them was Sen John Warner. " John Warner died in 2021. The current Senator Warner is Mark Warner.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Argh, fixed, thanks.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

In the Department of What Others Are Saying, I lifted this entire (public) comment (with links, which I'm not sure will translate). I hope that is not offensive here.

"Having failed or refused to create its own media universe in parallel to the GOP, Dems have gone "all-in" on a bet that general, popular media owned almost exclusively by corporations and billionaires will faithfully transmit its political messaging to the electorate.

Not only has this choice proven to be terrible, the intended recipients of the messaging are turning away from our chosen courriers of critical information in droves.

A lose-lose outcome.

Outlets seek fresh strategies as UK poll shows ‘news avoidance’ on the rise

Why millions of Americans avoid the news – and what it means for the US election

Can democracy survive if our Demz aren't learning?"

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Legacy media can still be useful, they just have to be played like the useful idiots they are. It doesn’t take a genius to figure out that cats like catnip.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I like yer style.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Amazing that “but her emails” is still a thing after almost a decade. The ability for Republicans to focus on a grievance (real or imagined) exists as a function outside of the media narrative. And because of that, the media will often follow.

Take a look at Cory Booker’s current talking filibuster (which I think is a good thing). He has described this effort as shining a light on the “abuses of the Trump administration”. But that’s a pretty broad and abstract concept to really land with the general public. It should have been about something specific — like Signalgate — which automatically forces the media to talk about that when they cover his filibuster (which they have).

Lack of message discipline isn’t the media’s fault. Just look at the Democratic response to Trump’s address to congress. It was all over the place, with many different messages and themes.

Learn a lesson from Republicans. People are simple. Pick an actionable message and repeat it over and over.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

Was that the lesson from Republicans? My impression is that their approach is "throw absolutely everything at the wall and wait until something sticks, then go in on that."

Like, almost nobody remembers this, but "Hillary's Emails" started out as Benghazigate, which originally wasn't even focused on Hillary but Obama, and when that didn't work, they tried to pin it on Hillary, and when that didn't work, it morphed into an all-purpose investigation of Hillary Clinton, and that eventually ended up centering on "her emails." It was four years of everything but the kitchen sink, most of which failed to stick, until eventually something did.

Of course, that strategy works well for them because the media repeats everything they say, amplifies everything they say, and treats it as serious as a heart attack.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Yes, they threw a lot of shit at the wall, but it was always on theme and incredibly simple: the Democrats are the enemy. Every Republican has been trotting out that message for decades.

Now we have a situation where Republicans literally are the enemy of many Americans, and still the Democrats can’t quite bring themselves to call out Republicans for being the enemy. Schumer still thinks the “fever will break”, as do many other Democrats who are on record saying the same shit.

We have oligarchs presenting themselves as also the enemy of the people, with Musk as their poster boy. But we still have Ben Wilker as DNC chair talking about “good billionaires”. And so-called progressives like Sen. Gallego chasing Marc Andreessen money.

They need to stop undermining the best and most clear message that Americans want to hear right now, and find a way to stay on theme and present a clear, simple and actionable message that people can rally around. They haven’t done that yet.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Democrats dinner is Thursday evening. I'll report back.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

It's media, mm. They decide what is a real scandal and what is not and they have decided to ignore national security breaches when done by Republicans.

In "green shoots" news - our multi county Democratic dinner is SOLD OUT It has not been sold out in the 25 years I've been involved in planning it.

A real opposition is building even here in deep Red Trump country.
Im really pleased.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

How long can we keep blaming the media for failure to keep our issues front and center? Especially when Democrats aren’t “flooding the zone”.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I see your point on complaining about media - it is tiresome. I guess I just don’t know what to do about what I see as blatant bias.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

We can try something new, or just do what the Republicans did. Work the refs, dismiss the “fake news” and get our own narratives out there. The Democrats would have to do all of that, and sustain it for a few years, for it to pay off.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I can't disagree with the fact of media bias. But that shouldn't keep Dems from doing more. Plus, spending some of the billions raised in campaigns on our own media.

Avatar

C P1 year ago

How long can we keep pretending the media isn't the main issue? Because that's far more common than the other problem. Don't confuse Balloon Juice with reality - out in meatspace, almost nobody I've ever talked to blames the media or even acknowledges its outsized influence or the strength of its bias, and I'm not talking about independents or low-infos or non-voters, this is true even of active and engaged partisan Democrats who haven't skipped an election since they turned eighteen.

I'm completely on board "work the refs, dismiss the fake news, and get our own narratives out there," but it's going to be one hell of an uphill battle, because right now, by and large not even our voters realize that there's a problem.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Like anything in life, we have a simple choice to make: change or accept. If we don’t like the media ecosystem, then we have to change it. And if we don’t want to change it (or can’t change it), then we must accept it for what it is.

When I start to see Democrats flood the zone, work the refs and create their own media narratives, and do it as consistently as Republicans have done, and it STILL doesn’t work, then we can talk about throwing in the towel. But we’re a long way from that.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Very happy to hear that grassroots opposition is rumbling along. The anger at the Trump administration is palpable, and even if the media doesn’t want to report it, they can’t just make it go away.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

The ability to control the narrative by flooding the zone has proved to be too much for some to stay focused enough to pick up the weapons laying right there, out in the open. Liberation Day approacheth like

Squirrel!