I’m at Lake Michigan and last evening I rode my bike down to the beach. On the way home a brief storm kicked up and it poured. I don’t think I have ridden a bike in a summer squall since I was 17. Wonderful.

I started blogging covering election law because Anne Laurie (stalwart Balloon Juice author and satirist), invited me to way back in 2009. I still follow election law - I’m by no means an expert but I do know more about election law and process than your average small town lawyer. If you want real analysis of election law and elections process, go two places - Election Law Blog and Inside Elections.

This is Inside Elections - a nice comparison of the rift in the Democratic Party base in 2025 versus the rift in the GOP base in 2009:

❝

Depending on what wing of the Democratic Party you belong to, Zohran Mamdani’s victory in the Democratic primary for mayor of New York City last week was either a warning shot or a cautionary tale. In picking the 33-year-old state assemblyman and self-described democratic socialist, Democratic voters dealt a stinging rebuke to the party establishment. That, in turn, has led to plenty of chatter that incumbent Democratic members of Congress could be vulnerable in their own primaries next year.

But we should be cautious about drawing conclusions based on a single election, especially one as unique as the New York City mayoral race. The issues and demographics of the country’s largest city are pretty different from those of most congressional districts. And Mamdani’s main opponent, former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, was a very flawed candidate (he resigned from office in the face of several sexual-harassment allegations, and he also faced criticism for his handling of COVID-19 in nursing homes). 

“Very flawed” is generous. The Right and Center of the Democratic Party put up an absolute scumbag for mayor of NYC. and ordered the base to back him. Unsurprisingly a big chunk of the base told them to get fucked. It’s not the first time either - the Center and Right’s last NYC candidate was Eric Adams. Christ almighty. It;’s like Donald Trump has given them permission to dramatically lower standards - they now think they can hire criminals.

Anyway! On to serious analysis!

❝

So we probably shouldn’t expect an unusual number of incumbents to go down in primaries next year. However, that doesn’t mean that the Democratic Party establishment can rest easy. The relatively high level of Democratic discontent could still manifest itself in open-seat races. The biggest impact of the Tea Party movement wasn’t incumbents losing primaries, but rather the proliferation of a new breed of uncompromising, anti-establishment conservatives that moved the Republican caucus right, obstructed legislation favored by GOP leadership, and ousted multiple speakers of the House. Similarly, MAGA-aligned legislators have displaced old-guard Republicans in Washington since President Donald Trump’s first election in 2016, predominantly not through defeating them in primaries, but succeeding them after they retired. Over on the Democratic side, most “Squad” members other than Ocasio-Cortez and Pressley — including Rashida Tlaib, Ilhan Omar, and Summer Lee — were first elected from open seats. And, of course, last week’s Democratic primary for mayor of New York City didn’t feature an incumbent either.

❝

Simply because of the sheer number of open seats (18 representatives have already retired or resigned this year, and the average cycle since 2009-10 has seen 52 representatives do so), one of the biggest things to watch for in the 2026 congressional primaries will be whether Democratic primary voters nominate more candidates opposed by party leadership. (Some more grist for this theory: Another CNN poll from April found that Democrats disapproved of the way Democratic leaders in Congress were handling their jobs, 57 percent to 42 percent. That’s much more overtly negative than their views of the party in general.) And if those candidates go on to win the general election, Democratic leaders in Congress could experience for themselves the same kind of intraparty strife that has plagued Republicans in recent years.

But history suggests that sitting Democratic members of Congress are in no special danger in 2026 primaries. Even in the most anti-incumbent election cycles, 95 percent or more of incumbents still win renomination.

Sadly, Gillibrand can probably rest easy and phone some more “work” in, she’s not going anywhere although I suspect Muslim voters heard her Islamophobia and bigotry loud and clear and won’t forget it. Probably no backsies on that.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Republicans were grabbing each other's butts on the house floor while giving all the money to ICE to uncitizen everyone.

https://www.reddit.com/r/gifs/comments/1lqqz3l/congressman_tenderly_grabs_another_congressman_on/

Avatar

C P1 year ago

"It;’s like Donald Trump has given them permission to dramatically lower standards - they now think they can hire criminals."

This is actually something I've brought up recurringly for the last decade at least - if we live in a world where Republicans get off scot-free for increasingly outrageous and criminal behavior while Democrats continue to be raked over the coals for the practical equivalent of farting in church, there's no way that doesn't seriously affect the integrity of Democratic nominees in time. You can't keep punishing good behavior and expect it to continue. Eventually the average Democrat's going to conclude "if I'm going to be treated as a crook no matter what, I might as well be a crook and at least get the benefits."

Hard to say whether this is an example of it or simply ordinary fuckery; it's not like there wasn't plenty of Democratic corruption all along, especially in New York. It's just... going to get much worse.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

"...polling does show relatively high levels of dissatisfaction with the Democratic Party among self-identified Democrats."

Emphasis mine.

Most of the people I butt heads with elsewhere go out of their way to proclaim their "progressiveness" but also go out of their way to proclaim they don't self-ID at Dems, They then proceed to tell people like me to stfu as they punch left, tell us that organized labor isn't worth supporting, quietly support the gutting of public education, crypto might not be all that bad and basically display the Blue MAGA mentality on a daily basis because it's designed to shut down dissent on candidates that, back in the day would be moderate, pro-choice Republicans.

And that's the rub, self-identified, lifetime Dems like me hate that so yeah, there's a schism if you want to call it that. We see where that's gotten us, dealignment:

https://newleftreview.org/sidecar/posts/dealignment

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

I agree with you to the extent that punching Left is somehow fine but punching Right is “disloyal”

Avatar

C P1 year ago

What's kind of extraordinary is how universal this is across the political spectrum.

If you're on the left side of the GOP, you're a RINO out of touch elitist, but if you're on the right side of the GOP, you're a salt-of-the-earth who represents the people.

If you're on the left side of the overall political spectrum, you're a commie intellectual liberal elitist, but if you're on the right side of the political spectrum, you're a salt-of-the-earth who represents the people.

If you're on the left side of the Democratic Party, you're a Berniebro, a Dirtbag Leftist, the reason Democrats lost, but if you're on the right side of the Democratic Party, you're a salt-of-the-earth who represents the people.

No matter where you are, everything is the fault of whoever's on your left, and the only way you can expiate your sins is to listen to the authentic popular voice of whoever's on your right.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

I mentioned in the post about Mamdani a few days ago that our white suburban relatives are all Blue MAGA. An infuriating tic they have is that just about any criticism of MAGA is denied (!!) because AFAWCT it would reflect poorly on their explicit MAGA buddies, who are such nice people they have known all their lives, so <insert MAGA insanity> can't possibly be true. But boy howdy do they love to punch left.

Also a while back I mentioned that Trump is indeed smart, because he refrains from attacking particular sets of Ds, such as the NY/NJ machine (national D leadership). They are, after all, helping him consolidate his power by play acting their roles. Trump recently bragged about Adams that "I had to help him out".

It's a very curious thing that both centrist Ds (Larry Summers! Bill Clinton! D Leadership!) and Trump himself have the knives out for Mamdani.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Not at all curious that clowns like Summers are saying what they're saying.

But hey, perhaps Larry's right with his predictions. After all, nobody knows how to create economic devastation quite like Larry "don't-you-dare-regulate-derivatives" or "10%-unemployment-on-purpose" Summers.

Not to mention his advisory role to the Yeltsin government after the fall of the USSR and we see how great that turned out.

He needs to be kidnapped by Kang and Kodos and anally probed with a butt plug in the shape of Alan Greenspan.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Also too, this reveals Summers for what he really is:

"Rent control is the second-best way to destroy a city, after bombing. And, because of what it leads to in terms of under investment in repairing, maintaining, constructing new apartments, I think this is likely to exacerbate rather than improve issues around housing affordability in New York. This would be a gross policy error by Mamdani."

The guy who gave banks $1 trillion while they foreclosed on millions of households is here to tell people about gross policy errors.

Reminder, in the 2009 global financial crisis, Summers advised Obama to save the bankers and let the mortgage holders drown. 10 million American families lost their homes. Thanks Obama!

Summers still loathes working people and still, always, serves billionaires.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

I am a registered Democrat, but it is not a core part of my identity. Having fewer people self-identify as Democrats in Colorado is actually a good thing and gives us more Democratic-leaning independents.

I am generally skeptical of independents and think they are people who are not well-versed on the issues, but if more of them are going to vote with Democrats, I am okay with it.

It was easy to be an independent in Colorado, and there are a lot of independents here. I did not become a Democrat until I moved to Maryland, and most things were decided in the Democratic primary.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

I’m also skeptical of independents, since the ones I have known are really just libertarians who want the freedom of voting Republican while pretending to be above the fray of politics.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Most that I've known are Embarassed Republicans.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Yes. In Colorado, that is shifting though. Some of it is "Democrats are not far enough left for me." or "Screw the Democrats for trying to sell out the trans vote."

Avatar

C P1 year ago

It's been a general part of my identity for much of my adult life, partly because the Democratic Party's been the crucible through which pretty much every worthwhile cause of the last 90 years had to pass in order to make it into politics. Even stuff that was once GOP bread and butter (civil rights) went nowhere until Democrats got into it.

... The thing is, all that was once true of the Republican Party too. And then it wasn't. The DLCish faction that got its hooks into the party in the Grant years eventually poisoned everything about it to the point that the only thing it knew how to do anymore was suck up to the rich. I'd like to believe the Democrats aren't there, but honestly the more I look at them, the more they remind me of early twentieth century Republicans.