Carbonated

Irrational exuberance:

The turbulence that hit stocks tied to artificial intelligence last week highlights a broader risk to the economy. Growth has become so dependent on AI-related investment and wealth that if the boom turns to bust, it could take the broader economy with it.

Business investment in AI might have accounted for as much as half of the growth in gross domestic product, adjusted for inflation, in the first six months of the year. Rising AI stocks are also boosting household wealth, leading to more consumer spending, especially in recent months.

“It’s certainly plausible that the economy would already be in a recession” without the AI boom, said Peter Berezin, chief global strategist at BCA Research.

Take away AI spending, and the economy looks in worse shape. Although job growth was higher than expected in September, job creation has nonetheless slowed this year and the unemployment rate is inching up. Private business investment excluding AI-related categories is mostly flat since 2019, according to Deutsche Bank. Outside of data centers, other commercial construction, such as shopping centers or office buildings, is down. 

That makes the economy more dependent on AI. “It’s the only source of investment right now,” said Stephen Juneau, an economist at Bank of America. 

Bank of America estimates that just four companies—Microsoft, Amazon.com, Alphabet and Meta Platforms—will make $344 billion in capital expenditures this year (equivalent to roughly 1.1% of GDP), up from $228 billion last year. 

The AI bubble means all investment is going to AI, which means very little is going anywhere else.

I spoke to my middle son yesterday; he’s an industrial high voltage electrician who works out of an IBEW local in Toledo. His local places electricians over a large jurisdiction - from west of Detroit to Fort Wayne, Indiana. He is taking a job building a data center for Google in Fort Wayne, Indiana on December 4th. Google is paying electricians better than anyone - between 4500 and 5400 weekly for this job. He could have taken a job building a data center for META in Wood County, Ohio. He says nearly his entire local is employed building data centers - nothing else is happening in any other area - and they need so many electricians they have driven up wages.

Good for him short term but bad for the country (and you, if your retirement is in a prudent, diversified mix of stocks across industries).

Reply

or to participate.