I took my 96 year-old dad to his 95 year-old sister’s place in Montana for her birthday, so I had my hands full the last couple of days. Now I’m back with a Montana update.
First, Kay wrote about the Montana ballot initiative that would regulate what corporations can spend for campaigns. This is a clever way to (partially) get around Citizens United. Unfortunately, the Montana AG (a Republican) won’t defend it:
Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen will not defend a recently passed citizen ballot initiative that he believes is unconstitutional.
Barely 24 hours after voters approved Ballot Initiative 194, known as the Montana Plan, by a nearly 2-1 margin, a coalition of conservative organizations filed suit in federal court to overturn the law. The suit was filed against Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen and Knudsen in their official capacities.
Friday, Knudsen filed a notice to the court that the initiative violates the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, and his office will not defend it. It sought to ban “artificial entities,” such as corporations and nonprofits, from directly spending money in elections.
Second, the Montana Senate race was a clusterfuck. Seth Bodnar, the former President of the University of Montana, ran as an independent with the backing of Jon Tester, but the Montana Democrats also ran a candidate, Alani Bankhead, who won apparently on the power of a bunch of third-party ads against Randy Neill, who said he wouldn’t drop out. Bankhead didn’t drop out, and both she and Bodner lost:

Another complication in the race was incumbent Republican Senator Steve Daines dropping out moments before the filing deadline, so his aide Kurt Alme could file instead. Still another complication was Jon Tester apparently losing it in his old age and shitting on the Democratic Party in Montana. Kate Riga has all the details in this TPM piece. Here’s a piece at LGM about Tester selling out. (FWIW, my aunt, a lifelong Democrat, voted for Bodnar.)
In general, the whole “run independents instead of Democrats” was an understandable strategy when it was cooked up in 2025. Each of the independents who ran in the plains/mountain states lost in their own special way. In Montana, Bodnar might have won as a Democrat. In the South Dakota US Senate race, Brian Bengs got slaughtered by incumbent Mike Rounds, but Bengs had run as a Democrat in a previous race so that kind of gives away his game. In Nebraska, Dan Osborne came somewhat close (50/44) but still didn’t make it against incumbent Senator Pete Rickets. In Idaho, Todd Achilles also got slaughtered by incumbent Senator Jim Risch.
The Bodnar loss is the one that hurts, as far as I’m concerned, because Montana is pretty red, but there’s a chance for a Democrat, as demonstrated by Sam Forstag. He won MT-1, which is the western quarter of Montana that includes the cities of Missoula, Bozeman, Butte and Kalispell.
The whole independent phenomenon mainly shows that there’s no shortcut to the long-term project of rehabilitating the Democratic Party in these rural western red states. If you can open voters’ minds a bit, and run a decent candidate, you can get a win every so often in these conservative states. I think that’s a better strategy that running independents.
Another bright spot in Montana is that the House minority leader is going to be a non-binary trans person, SJ Howell, and the minority whip will be trans woman Zooey Zephyr. One of the characteristics of Democrats in rural red states is that they are so used to being criticized by Republicans for their views that they develop a tough skin. Zephyr and Howell being elected to leadership by their fellow Democrats demonstrates this. (My aunt said that she was sitting with a group of friends at a restaurant and someone remarked that if a bomb hit it, half of the Democrats in the county would be killed. This is what it’s like to be a Democrat in some of those rural areas.)
The overall party splits in the Montana legislature are 58 R / 42 D in the House and 32 R / 18 D in the Senate. Piece of shit Gian Gianforte is still Governor — he’s the guy who assaulted a journalist in 2017 when he was a US Representative.
Back to my dad and aunt: they are total normie Democrats who just want the party to win. Their issues are healthcare and benefits for the poor. My aunt is a former teacher and had a lot of stories about kids being hungry in school. Dad’s a former doctor and wants some kind of universal health care. They believe the things that Democrats on TV say, and they think that Democrats will do their best when in power to do good things for people who need government help. Part of the rage that I feel about the corporate wing of the Democratic Party is that people like my dad and aunt have contributed to candidates who have lied to them, repeatedly. They deserve better.

