I finally got around to watching AOC’s almost two hour Instagram live on the Speaker election. This guy posted it to YouTube if you want to watch it:

Here are the key points:

  • The speaker’s job is both legislative and political:

    • Legislative - deciding which bills hit the floor (after listening to his caucus)

    • Political - ensuring a majority for his party

  • Generally, the speaker is going to be a “mean” Democrat — he representes the midpoint between the most conservative and most liberal members of his caucus

  • She is not interested in running for Speaker — not her “ministry”. She’s more of an organizer.

  • The real Speaker election occurs in a closed caucus meeting using a secret vote in a couple of weeks.

  • Since nobody has challenged Jeffries for Speaker, there’s nobody else to choose for speaker.

  • The combination of the New Democrats caucus plus the Blue Dogs caucus is a bigger vote than the Progressive caucus, so there’s no way a progressive could win Speaker right now.

  • The floor vote is a formality, and any members who choose to vote against Jeffries on the floor vote should prepare to be relegated to the least relevant committees.

Activists like Indivisible were pushing Ayanna Pressley as an alternative to Jeffries, but Pressley hasn’t decided to run, so Jeffries is going to win. Some other activists I’ve seen are angry about that and are going to treat a floor vote for Jeffries as some kind of litmus test. If you’re interested in progressive legislation, that’s not the smart move. You should recognize that there’s not real alternative to Jeffries and that progressives should make a loyalty vote for Jeffries so they can get better committee assignments and move a progressive agenda forward.

AOC is now on Energy and Commerce, a power committee, and she notes that she tried to get on there a couple times previously. One of those times, she was edged out by a member who was the deciding vote against an important healthcare reform and then retired. So, committee assignments matter.

That all said, I’m not going to get scoldy about people who are fired up after the latest win and want to make Jeffries a litmus test. The more that he is viewed as toxic, the better chances that he’ll be replaced in 2028 or sooner. The more that members have to explain their votes for Jeffries, the better educated their constituents will be. It will be an opportunity for members to be honest with the people who elected them, which is a good thing as far as I’m concerned. There’s so much consultant-driven dishonesty in the members’ messaging that any opportunity to be frank with them is an opportunity to strengthen the party.

As usual with her livestreams, AOC answers a bunch of other questions, including some about the role of campaign donations from big donors. The whole thing is worth a watch.

During the livestream, she says that “this will make people mad” a number of times, and then points out that she’s just relating how things are, not how she wants them to be. I get that this pisses off people who want her to be their political “everything”, but we’ve elected a lot more progressive Representatives and Senators, so people like Peggy Flanagan, Scott Colom, AES, Melat Kiros and others can help shoulder the burden of the slow but inevitable change that’s coming for our party.