When I lived in Rochester, I, and everyone else, was acquainted with the work of Rachel Barnhart. Barnhart was a reporter for a couple of different local TV stations. She was generally a good journalist, a bit quirky and prone to getting into personality conflicts. Barnhart ran for a number of different political offices in Rochester, as a Democrat, and finally won a seat on the County Legislature. She has a contentious relationship with the Democratic majority on the Leg.

When I heard that Barnhart was running for office, I thought it was great — I knew that she’d definitely be the kind to give an inside perspective on running for and serving in office. Her Substack does not disappoint, and there’s an interesting story there.

Basically, the County Leg has $25 million of anti-poverty funds to disburse. Rochester has a big urban poverty problem, and there have been dozens, if not hundreds, of attempts to change that. This $25 million is going to be spent in part on $1,000 monthly subsidies for pregnant women, and for rental subsidies for people who qualify. But $16.8 million is going to be spent on this:

Yep, they’re going to make these small payments based on achievements. I’m sure it won’t surprise you to learn that $6.5 of the $16.8 million will be spent on administrative costs. How the hell else would you be able to track and disperse these relatively tiny payments? This is “better a thousand people go hungry than one undeserving person get a free lunch” means testing in action. $300 to get your GED? Come on.

This unproven, obviously (to me) silly effort is the work of a Boston non-profit called Empath. Rachel’s post goes through all the lack of scientific basis, and the possible conflicts of interest of this program, as you’d expect from a top-notch journalist. Read that at her site if you’re interested.

Part of the dynamic here is that Rochester’s county government was Republican-run until a few years ago, a hangover from the days when Republicans were fairly liberal in New York State. (They’re MAGA now). A few years ago, Democrat Adam Bello ran and won the County Executive seat. He’s from Irondequoit, a suburb north of the city. Bello is part of the Morelle machine, led by Joe Morelle, who was Andrew Cuomo’s ally as majority leader in the State Assembly, until he ran and won the NY-25 congressional seat to represent Rochester. Morelle and Bello are white guys from the suburbs. I’m not surprised that this cockamamie plan came from their rule, since it provides an opportunity to “fight poverty” while letting a bunch of contractors get their beaks wet.

County leadership doesn’t like Barnhart, but, unlike them, Barnhart cares about the city. She’s a white woman who’s in her 40s who attended and graduated from inner-city schools, where her parents taught. Today, she lives in another inner city neighborhood. She is sincerely interested in ending poverty in Rochester, she loves the city, and she’s part of it in a way that few white people are. She’s far from perfect, but I sure don’t doubt her sincerity nor her bona fides.

I’m sure dumb plans like this are wasting money all over the nation. I just know about this one because I lived in Rochester and still read some of the news from there.

Edit: Rachel reached out on BlueSky to correct one thing:

So even worse — the County Leg doesn’t even get a vote on these kinds of initiatives.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

r po1 year ago

I am learning more about the um imperfect nature of US political machines from this blog in the last months than the previous 30 years combined. Thank you very much. I find it intensely fascinating in a morbid way. Also enlightening.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

And not just MM. Kay is really bringing it too. Yall keep this up and I'm going to demand to pay something. It would be the very first site I pay for.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Thanks! We're trying!

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

A Democratic majority passed this? Wow. Here’s the thing, we are so worried about accusations of fraud by disingenuous Republicans that we literally waste money ourselves to prevent it. So ridiculously stupid.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

They're on track to pass it. They hid it from everyone (including Barnhart) because a core group of Democrats don't want to have a debate on it. She ferreted it out and then published it.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Good for her. That tactic sounds soooooo familiar. And people ask why I rail on certain elements of Dems, this is why.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

I hope Rachel Barnhart stays fierce and has success in her endeavors! I too still read news from my old hometown and, although the "Delco Pooper" grabbed too many recent headlines, Delco is Finding Out the hard way about many rethuglucan leftovers and not so old gambits such as private equity hollowing out the ONLY healthcare system that serves its only city (Crozer Chester Medical Center closed its doors for good this week, after milking donations from County benefactors to help it stay open - lawsuits to claw some back have been filed), and charter school criminals doing negligence and abuse to poor children at every turn...

We need every eagle-eyed, fierce, righteous woman and good hearted man we can get! The blatant and also covert corruption is so over the top everywhere....

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

She's definitely paid the price for being fierce. I think part of her political career stems from nobody in Rochester media wanting to hire her. She had a lawsuit with one former employer, for example.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

Some of those training and education programs are scams. There were a lot of "code schools" that were mostly fake with poor curriculum set up, and when people told me about their shiny program that I applied to, they said that they could not say anything against it because the rich lady who started it was doing other business with the chamber of commerce.

We also love to charge a premium when Americans create poorly paid textile jobs for women in other countries.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Non-profits by definition don't make a profit, but that doesn't mean that some politicians kid or relative can't bring down a fat salary running one. That's part of the issue, I think.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

Example Gazillion of another right-wing, libertarian policy that's baked into both sides of the aisle.

All anyone has to do is search:

the fallacy of means testing

to see how many glibertarian think tanks love them their means testing.

Some history of it from the Dem side: https://prospect.org/economy/fight-means-testing-really/

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Another issue is the jillion little programs each designed to fix one tiny special issue that their benefactor thinks is the key to poverty.