❝

In competitive states, Trump is weakest in New Hampshire and Pennsylvania, where just 39% of voters approve of how he’s handling trade, followed closely by Nevada at 40% and Michigan at 41%. These are states where the margin of victory in the 2024 presidential elections was razor-thin, so a twenty-point deficit for the president represents meaningful degradation in support for his agenda.

And even in swing states where Trump performed better in 2025, he remains firmly underwater on tariffs. On average, in all competitive states, Trump's approval on tariffs is 10 points below his vote share in the 2024 presidential election.

So this is a point of vulnerability for Republicans, but just describing tariffs as “a tax increase” and leaving it at that is arguing on GOP turf (anti tax).

Instead, let’s describe tariffs as a regressive tax (as opposed to income tax, which is progressive) where the tariff/tax burden falls hardest on lower- and middle-income people:

❝

Based on this initial analysis, it appears tariffs are imposed in a regressive manner – in part because expenditures on traded goods are a higher share of income and non-housing consumption among lower income households, but also due to explicit regressivity within categories. 

Gavin Newsome makes this “regressive tax” argument when he’s comparing California to Texas and Florida. Texas and Florida have low (or no) progressive taxation but they load up poor and middle income with a disproportionate share of taxes using sales taxes and fees and what it costs to replace public services they don’t provide.

I think this argument has gotten some traction - there’s a whole Tik Tok genre of people who moved to Florida from states like NY or CT or MA and they find that when they add it all up Florida is as expensive as those higher tax states, just with fewer services and lower quality of life.

We (of course) don’t have to say “regressive tax”. Instead we can say Donald Trump and Republicans are “nickel and diming” the working and middle class to death. It’ll be easy to do- grocery prices are thru the roof.

*photo is a sweet pea from my garden

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Krugman's entry today is about the tariffs trade war being regressive (he actually uses that word).

"...Trump’s trade war should be seen as part of a package of policies that amounts to class warfare — class warfare against middle and lower-income Americans in favor of the affluent, especially the top 10 percent of the income distribution."

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

"Tariffs as regressive tax increases that help pay for regressive tax cuts"

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Adding it up, so to speak, without actually saying it

https://bsky.app/profile/deirdreassenza.bsky.social/post/3lvyo4i3wgc2e

Great background music, goes with the overall vibe 😎

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

These days, driving a point home with the masses has to be simple and visual.

Flood social media with a bunch of folks waving their Texas property tax bills around, and wait for the meme to take hold. Shit, call it the “property tax challenge” and it may very well go viral.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

I think “regressive tax” is too sophisticated for most people to understand. Me personally, I think Democrats need a better angle entirely. Probably best to hold a little powder until the effects really kick in and start driving prices and inflation higher.

Those are the things that people can see and feel. It’s a simple argument. That is largely what drove so many non-MAGA people to vote from Trump. Live by the price index, die by the price index.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Just saying rich people aren't hurt by tariffs but working class and poor are, then pointing to the price of everything probably works...

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Yup, that would do it!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

This story from Wednesday warms my heart

"Secretary Linda McMahon was trolled by a hacker who hijacked the sound system and played circus music over remarks she gave during an appearance at a Young America’s Foundation event for conservative youth.

At one point, McMahon was cut off by audio of someone calling her a "corrupt billionaire who knows nothing about education," prompting her to look around nervously."

Heh.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

When I lived in NY, there were a lot of tax whiners who moved to Texas and Florida. Good riddance -- they were assholes, in general. But they also left after their kids got a world-class education in NY public schools. Other older folks whose kids had graduated from school started voting against school bond issues. The "I got mine" brigade. These people are beyond help, but the young folks who use the services aren't.

For example, in the suburb where we lived, the old "I got mines" voted against a school bond issue, and the youngs retaliated by voting against a bond issue to renovate and expand the library, which was backed by the olds. So, after that, the school bond issue passed and then the library bonds. It was the bond issue equivalent of mutually assured destruction.

Young people who are just starting out, buying houses (that use Canadian lumber at 35% tariffs), buying cars, furniture, things for their kids, etc. can see this as a tax on them.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur1 year ago

Gouging is also a good word, readily understood by all. And "picking your pockets."

All in service of lower taxes for billionaires.

PS your photo brought back childhood memories of The Bulletin (now defunct Philly newspaper) comics section and Popeye's adopted nephew Swee' Pea.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

The same stories apply to Texas. People think it's same wonderful place to live out the "taxes are theft" mythical lifestyle only to learn what you describe. And property taxes are where people go into sticker shock.

Rocket Mortgage has a piece on this: https://www.rocketmortgage.com/learn/property-taxes-by-state

Anytime I see a story about some moran moving to TX because NO INCOME TAX, then finds out within 2 years they're paying more, I LOL.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

It’s interesting to me because this argument has been out there on the Left for a long time, and it finally is getting some traction. Proof that if we just keep hitting it it seeps in eventually.

Avatar

John S.1 year ago

Wow. That extra 1% in property tax (that you really can’t cheat on) is really gonna sting. I had no idea Texas was so high!

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

That's Kay's point. Many of us on the left have known about this for a looooong time and point it out whenever this subject comes up. Hell, I've seen people on forums totally unrelated to politics learn about the realities of NO INCOME TAX PARADISES!!!!!!! like FL and TX.

Most also don't seem to care about services that don't exist in those places that they just assume do because in their "tax is theft" state they're seeking to flee has them.

Morans.