Joe’s good post on the Tea Party got me thinking about something I’ve been wanting to write about for a while: the Tea Party and abortion.

Let’s start with Roe v Wade. Overall, I think this decision was bad for Democrats, but good for women. The reason it was bad for Democrats is because it really fed into the idea that Democratic legislators wouldn’t have to work too hard. As long as the apolitical legal superheroes on the Court were appointed by Democratic Presidents, they would serve to uphold what we thought were the generally-agreed-upon liberal principles that all right-thinking educated people accepted. And, until the Trump disaster, they weren’t wrong. Obergefell is another example. Democratic politicians didn’t have to get their hands dirty doing the hard political work of advocating for abortion or gay marriage, the court and its right-thinking heroic justices would do that for them.

In fairness to Democrats, they saw what happened when they legislated in the wake of a court decision. After Brown vs Board, the Civil Rights Act lost the South for Democrats for generations. We’re still dealing with the fallout from that.

Prior to Trump, the Republican Party was governed by elites who pandered to their base but didn’t give them the results they wanted. Reagan, Bush I and Bush II didn’t really care about abortion or gay marriage. Reagan and the elite Bushes lived in a world where abortion and homosexuality were quietly accepted. They didn’t really give a shit if non-elite women had abortions or if homosexuals were allowed to marry — their concerns weren’t social issues, but rather that they and their cohort could make as much money with as little tax as possible, all while raping the environment. They also weren’t overt racists and, in general, considered racism a bit gauche. (Of course they were structural racists, since they wanted the brown and black poor to stay subjugated to the white elite.) Bush II also realized that racism against Mexican-Americans was stupid, because a lot of the immigrant Mexicans were pretty conservative and amenable to Republican policies.

So, up until the election of Barack Hussein Obama, the Republican Party was able to placate their base in much the same way that establishment Democrats placate theirs: by saying things they agree with, but not executing on their major policy preferences, most notably abortion. Obama’s election changed all that. We can argue about whether the Tea Party movement was a Fox News Frankenstein that got out of hand, or if there was a group of Republican elites who wanted this radical faction to rule the party. No matter what the genesis of the Tea Party, when Trump latched onto it, that’s all she wrote for the white Republican educated elites. Their party was taken over by the voters that they thought they could manipulate and control.

As Joe pointed out in yesterday’s post, this hyper-motivated group controls the Republican Party by a couple of percentage points in low-turnout primaries. Still, they’ve gotten what they wanted. Abortion has been repealed in their benighted states, and their elected representatives and court are working to deny that right to most women. Using the wedge issue of trans rights, they’re working up the anti-LGBTQ+ hatred that will justify the denial of gay marriage in their states after the Court inevitably overturns Obergefell.

In short, it’s pretty good times for the white reactionary Tea Partiers, not that you’d be able to tell from their constant whining. The statistically significant decline in the standard of living, lifespan and quality of life in their strongholds means little to them because they’d rather have a dime instead of a dollar if they can be sure that poor brown and black people have only a couple of pennies.

The Republican base got what they wanted. The Democratic base hasn’t. If Democrats win in 2028, we’ll be in the same place that the Republican base was during the Bush administration: we "won” but we probably won’t get our preferred policies. If, as Joe suggests, we start our own version of the Tea Party, we’d better be sure that our electeds get the messages about our pet issues, which include health care and making sure that the Trumpers pay for what they did. And we also better be patient and play the long game, since it took Republicans 50 years to repeal Roe.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 6 months ago

I’ve been reading the political science lit on right-wing populism a lot lately, and I think all y’all’s instincts about them are pretty accurate.

It’s a little foggy, but it appears these movements are fueled by a segment who feels a loss of relative (!!!) social or economic status (probably both in most cases). The economic portion turns into anger that feeds cultural resentment. The social status loss goes straight to cultural resentment.

Here it’s Christian, patriarchal, White and straight.

(My interpretation here.) Obama’s election freaked em out, all “I want my country back!” But a lot of em got closer to the poor since ‘80, and that slowly burned a hole in their senses that demagogues could fill with “immigrants jumping the line,” “welfare for immigrants,” “urban crime,” and whatever other scapegoating.

They remain a small segment. It’s a pity Dems let inequality fester after Bush I—could be smaller. Also a pity: low-info voters rolling the dice to help those dicks.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

Relative loss of social and economic status is the key I think. Lots of zero sum thinking, too.

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 6 months ago

Totally. If relative status is your bag, you are locked into zero-sum thinking. Some of the lit makes this point explicitly.

Strangely, left-wing populism is boosted by overall economic loss. RW populists appear to oppose redistribution, which is crazy but will not surprise anyone here.

Avatar

C P6 months ago

IIRC, when they looked at the demographics of the Nazi Party, they found that even the most "populist" elements of it (the Brownshirt types) weren't working class, so much as fallen middle-class types (often small businessmen) whose jobs were hit by the Great Depression and resented the loss of status.

(And also resented the lifelong working class folks for having all those support networks in place, from unions to charities, to help weather adversity. Networks the middle class folks had always looked down on as for losers and bums).

Avatar
Avatar

r po6 months ago

Yeah MM, I think this pretty much sums it up. For decades my wife said this all started with Reagan, and now I agree with her.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago(edited)

Raygun was my very first protest. I was the only protester in my town at that rally. My dad came along because of all the snipers on rooftops. Fittingly, it was in 1984.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

I remember as a teenager thinking that Reagan was terrible and how would we survive. I mean, Trump-level disgust at the guy. He was kind of like Trump in that he wasn't the smartest but he had same kind of instinctual political talent that Trump has.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago(edited)

And the same degenerative dementia type illness.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

I love that Colbert presented Chef José Andrés with a check for over $2 million as one of his last acts on the show. Jimmy Kimmel is off air tonight in honor of the last show, a wonderful tribute. I haven't watched CBS in aeons and tonight will be the very last time (I used to love CBS Sunday Morning every weekend but gave it up). I am in a bit of mourning today.

Avatar

Kay W.6 months ago

It’s been a bit of a gut punch finding out how much this country hates women. I was naive. I had no idea. Now I know.

Avatar

r po6 months ago

So my wife and I were visiting her BFF in downtown Atlanta in 2024, and this friend is aghast that Trump looks to win again, and her friend says: women will save us.

I said, no they won't. That didn't go over well. But it turned out to be true.

I apologize that we men are so shitty, but it's not all our fault. I remain astounded by Southern "Culture".

Racism is a powerful death wish. 5 years in Atlanta starting 1980 and I never could have imagined this happening decades later.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

I thought we would rise up in bigger numbers too.

Avatar

Kay W.6 months ago

When Roe was overturned I read a long piece in the New Yorker about the elite religious Right (primarily Catholics) and how they were confident Americans really wouldn’t give a shit about women bleeding out in hospital parking lots once the initial shock wore off. They were right. That’s turned out to be true.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago(edited)

🤬😤 wait till their own daughters die in back alleys because the Supremacists are coming for medication abortion after the midterms

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

If you look at the reports it's clearly women who aren't members of the elite -- they're poor and generally not white. In other words, working as planned. Those are the people the Tea Party wants punished, and it's happening.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Long game played & still have no 28th Amendment despite Biden's proclamation after the Supremacists made presidents into kings. If Dotard made that same proclamation it'd be considered the law of the land right now.

When Biden stated that the ERA has been ratified "...the National Archives has said they do not intend to certify the amendment as part of the Constitution, citing "established legal, judicial, and procedural decisions" supporting the integrity of the original ratification deadline in the absence of any subsequent extension or deadline removal by Congress or the court system. Biden's statement led to widespread criticism, with the Washington Post's analysis concluding "it's also remarkable that a president would try to declare something that isn't clearly the law to be not just the law, but part of the most significant legal document our country has. [How quaint!] That at the very least skips over a whole lot of very valid legal issues that have never been settled."

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

So I'll add the Equal Rights Amendment to my wish list!

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Exhibit A:

"The Trump administration does not plan to seek approval from Congress for President Trump’s planned 250-foot arch, arguing that they do not need it because lawmakers a century ago authorized a somewhat similar project that was never built."