A reader sent this one to me and I wanted to highlight it:

CORCA is the Combatting Organized Retail Crime Act. Here’s the one-pager bullet-point list of what the bill does [pdf]. From my cursory, non-specialist reading, most of it seems pretty basic, such as treating gift cards as money for the purposes of money laundering statutes, and aggregating the theft totals of small thefts over the period of a year so if it’s more than $5,000, it’s subject to federal prosecution.

But it also establishes an Organized Retail and Supply Chain Crime Coordination Center within the Department of Homeland Security. This is a data collection center, and some justice non-profits are upset about that:

❝

CORCA encourages broad data-sharing between retailers and federal law enforcement without clear limits or oversight,” said Aiden Cotter, director of Federal Advocacy at Vera Action, a New York-based justice nonprofit launched in 2021. ”Because private companies are not bound by the Fourth Amendment in the same way the government is, retailers could collect and share large amounts of customer surveillance and behavioral data with DHS—potentially creating a backdoor surveillance system with little judicial review or transparency.” 

CORCA achieves that goal by creating a new “national intelligence hub” that reports directly to the Department of Homeland Security. The center’s director will be named by acting ICE Director David Venturella, and will be empowered to work “directly with retailers” to collect data on any person a retailer accuses of engaging in “organized retail theft.”

The bill’s language doesn’t include a single safeguard limiting what data can be collected, how it can be used, or who DHS can share the data with once it falls into government hands.

I can’t think of any reason why any Democrat would sign onto this in the context of the way ICE has been acting in the Trump Administration. The overall merits of the bill are irrelevant — if it’s that good, we can pass it in 2028, with some serious oversight attached. A message needs to be sent by the opposition party about DHS funding, and, clearly, it wasn’t with the passage of CORCA.

Digging into the roll call, I see the Democratic Nays are all the Democrats who I think get it — AOC, Becca Balint, Ilhan Omar, Greg Casar, and a bunch of others. There are a few I want to call out in the context of the Colorado politics I’m trying to learn.

First, Diana DeGette (CO-1) voted “Nay”. I’ll bet you a few tacos at your favorite Denver-area taco truck that she would have voted “Yea” if she didn’t have a serious primary challenge from Melat Kiros. Second, Joe Neguse (CO-2), who is clearly angling to move up in leadership, voted “Yea”. He’s supposedly a progressive, and he represents a D+20 district — this should have been an easy “Nay”. Jason Crow (CO-6) betrayed his 22% hispanic D+11 district, which includes Aurora, where ICE has been wilding, by voting “Yea”. Brittany Petterson (CO-7), who’s my new rep, voted “Nay”. She represents a D+8 suburban Denver district, and I’m thinking she might be better than expected. Perhaps she’s been radicalized by the experience of having to fly to DC almost immediately after giving birth with a newborn in arms because the Republicans decided to fuck around with proxy voting. (I’m pleasantly surprised by this vote — she currently holds the tightest CO district that has a Democrat representing it. Good for her.)

As far as I’m concerned, any vote by a Colorado Democrat that gives a penny to any arm of the DHS that’s anywhere near ICE is inviting a primary challenge. I’d love to see some loudmouth young hippie from Boulder go at Joe Neguse. Ditto for Crow, though it should be a loudmouth Mexican-American from Aurora who should challenge this pendejo.

I think it’s a worthwhile exercise to click on the roll call for this bill and look at your state delegation, as well as the Democrats you think are worth supporting. With everything that’s going on with the Trump Administration, this vote was under the radar. Unfortunately for those of us hoping for big change from the Democratic Party, it showed that there are roughly 60 who will do the right thing when nobody is looking. We have a long way to go.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Scott H6 months ago(edited)

Petterson's a yimby, I'd never vote for her. Being that, she's as Abundo/MattY/3rd Way as most Dems so while let's applaud her sorry ass for this vote, that's not see at as a harbinger of turning into an AOC.

Neguse is massively overrated as a 'progressive' so his vote didn't surprise me, nor did Crow who, while not a yimby, is probably closer to a Blue Dog 1.0 (he's a 'New Democrat' so is a Blue Dog 2.0) than people like to think.

Our Invisible Congresswoman voted 'nay' for the reasons you outlined.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

See, I get more upset with Neguse's vote than any bad vote Petterson takes because the D+20 dems should all be pretty darn left, whereas Petterson rep'ing a D+8 district makes it less of a blue safe seat.

Avatar

John S.6 months ago

Oh good. Another vote, another reason to be disappointed with Rep. Kim Schrier.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Avatar

Ken In MN6 months ago

Soooo not surprised to see that the corporate and crypto-owned Eric Trump BFF Angie Craig voting yea...

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

Man I hope Craig isn't your next Senator.

Avatar

Scott H6 months ago

Butbutbutbut, she's Talented!.

Avatar

Sepideh M6 months ago

When Joe Neguse was first elected, he had one foot in with the lefties and one foot in with the current power structure in the Democratic Party. He has decided to climb in with one group while abandoning the other. This is disappointing. He touts working across the aisle a lot, and he is onboard with Senator Bennet's campaign for governor.

A lot of the locals are supporting Phil Weiser for governor.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

Yeah I'm certainly not voting for Bennet.

Avatar

Scott H6 months ago

I'll vote for Weiser in the primary but if Bennet wins, I won't vote for him in Nov. I won't vote for whatever right-wing loon the state GOP nominates but enough is enough.

Weiser won't be any screaming progressive governor by any stretch but if he's marginally better than our outgoing, glibertarian, techbro dooooooshbag, it'll be an improvement.

Avatar

Kay W.6 months ago

VERA is very well regarded in juvenile crim justice circles. If VERA Action is their lobbying group the concerns about a lack of oversight are legit.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Re: another DHS harbinger found at Will Bunch bsky:

https://bsky.app/profile/maddow.bsky.social/post/3mlvx6qpik22i

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

I obvs don't have any Dem representation to check up on. My only "Dem" is Fetterman.

Avatar

C P6 months ago

In what fucking universe is retail theft a homeland security concern, even if it was a real problem and not a bad joke. Does MI5 handle noise complaints? Did the KGB hand out parking tickets?

This really is the stupidest descent into dictatorship ever.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Data is very valuable currency.

Avatar

C P6 months ago

Yeah, I know. It's just a preposterous justification, is all.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Maybe it's helpful that all the goon legislation has opposite naming in backwards land, it's easier to know what it's not doing just by looking at the names. Kinda like how our adversaries are learning national security secrets by watching the insider trades.

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 6 months ago

Spot on. Not only is it not a problem, it’s a moral panic and essentially a conspiracy theory. If Books Could Kill did an episode on it:

https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/if-books-could-kill/id1651876897?i=1000632623232

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Sounds like the authors of the bill are anticipating upcoming shortages resulting in an uptick of retail theft for some reason...

Also, this reminds me of the ChatGPT access to bank account data I mentioned yesterday:

"The bill’s language doesn’t include a single safeguard limiting what data can be collected, how it can be used, or who DHS can share the data with once it falls into government hands."

Are the yea Dems really this clueless or are they beholden to the same special interests as Rethugs?

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Received an email alert about additional fuckery from takeitback.org yesterday:

"The so-called Digital Asset Market Clarity Act isn’t actually about clarity at all -- it’s about stripping regulators of the authority they need to police a high-risk industry.

At its core, the bill would weaken the power of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, the one body with a proven record of protecting investors from fraud, manipulation, and deceptive financial products.

By narrowing how digital assets are defined and shifting oversight away from securities law, the Act would allow many crypto offerings to avoid the disclosure, registration, and anti-fraud requirements that apply to stocks and other traditional investments. This would make it easier to market a new wave of “investment products” that are more risky than they appear."

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Received plenty of Dem votes, apparently

Avatar

Busted Knee6 months ago

Tech and finance is a blue state product. If you can't figure out that the things we are complaining about are our products, make us donor states, and allow our educated professionals to make comfortable incomes you are missing the entire problem with liberalism and the Democrats. It simply cannot be fixed.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Check the nym. It's "Dinosaur" for a reason. I don't have anything to do with these products except being one by design not under my control. I delete as many apps as possible from my phone, don't use AI, no social media etc.

So, as usual, I'm an outlier. But I get your point.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

I'd gladly participate in destroying the internet forever if I could. I was happier in the before computers age. I'd telephone my opinions in to the Sound Off hotline at our local newspaper and clip the ones that got printed for my scrapbook. So grateful my childhood was in the before computers and cell phones time.

https://youtu.be/GDElHjyN_Eg?si=DhCmdSVU_d2CeS_h

Avatar

C P6 months ago

Are the yea Dems really this clueless or are they beholden to the same special interests as Rethugs?

Much as I hate to be the "por que no los dos" wiseass...

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

I love the smell of smartass remarks in the morning.