Yadira Caraveo is a dream candidate. She's the daughter of undocumented immigrants, born in Denver, who became a pediatrician, a member of the Colorado House, and then the person representing CO-8 in the United States Congress. CO-8 is rated EVEN by the Cook Political Report. She won in 2022 and was beat by Gabe Evans in 2024.

Reader S sent me these not-so-good clips from her interview with Kyle Clark, who’s probably the best journalist in Colorado (and, maybe, in the nation). It did not go well:

❝

Fmr Dem Rep Caraveo says the GOP’s Laken Riley Act focused on “the supposed criminality of immigrants” and was “designed just to win districts.” Yet Caraveo voted for it.

Fmr Dem Rep Caraveo voted with the GOP to allow the incoming Trump administration to strip nonprofits of their tax status, declaring them supporters of terrorism. Caraveo said she liked another provision in the bill and backed it because she knew Biden wouldn’t sign it into law.

Fmr Dem Rep Caraveo acknowledges she voted for GOP messaging bills and priorities that she says would have been harmful if they became law. Despite her efforts to craft a moderate image in her swing district, she still lost. I asked her if it was worth it.

Caraveo, who had a progressive record in the state legislature, says her newfound centrism in Congress was an effort to vote her district’s values, not her own. She declined to provide a specific example of when she voted against her own values.

Caraveo has launched her campaign for CO-8 without endorsements from any of Colorado’s top Democrats who worked with her in Congress and the state legislature. Caraveo says she hasn’t sought public endorsements.

Caraveo faces State Rep Manny Rutinel in a Democratic primary to determine who will face GOP Rep Gabe Evans. Rutinel has committed to appearing on Next in May after the state legislative session. Evans has not yet accepted an open invitation for an interview.

I watched the interview on YouTube. She’s smart, candid about her depression (she checked herself into Walter Reed during her term in Congress, good for her) and has huge potential as a candidate. Her record in the Colorado House was pretty good. But, as you can see above, Clark has her dancing because she fucked up on immigration. She took some bad votes in the House, and Clark goes at her hard about those.

Her defense is that those were “messaging votes” not real votes, and she knew that Biden wouldn’t sign them into law. Well, maybe that made sense when the DCCC-approved consultants were urging her to take those votes, but it looks pretty fucking stupid right now. (The reason I think that DCCC consultants advised her is that an EVEN district is where the DCCC is more than willing to invest money in a promising candidate.)

Again, she’s smart and, obviously, she cares. So I’m giving her a small benefit of the doubt by saying that consultants told her to take those votes. (By “small” I mean that I think she wouldn’t have done it without outside pressure.) No matter, her interview is 20 minutes of trying to explain her dumb votes. For example:

❝

Clark: […] this is the second time we’ve run into this. This is the second time you’ve said, well, you’ve voted for something even though it was a bad idea because I knew it wasn’t going to become law. Is that what folks send you to Washington to do?

Caraveo: I think that they send you to do all of the calculations on legislation, to weigh all of the risks and benefits, like you do when you go to the doctor, you say, ‘hey I have cancer, should I have chemotherapy or not?’ Chemotherapy might help with some issues and it might make others difficult. It’s a constant calculation that you have to do in the same way as a legislator…

If there was a more clear example of “if you’re explaining, you’re losing” than this, I don’t know what it is.

Caraveo has a primary challenger and, frankly, I hope that person beats her. My bet is that anyone with a D after their name can win CO-8 in 2026, and if we’re going to hold CO-8 after that, we need someone who has the sense to articulate and vote on their own deeply held beliefs.

There are so many other ways a hispanic woman with Caraveo’s life history could have handled the immigration issue. She could have voted no on these messaging bills, because, as she explained, the votes were meaningless, so why not use that as a justification? She could have talked about her history as a child of undocumented, and I’m sure hard-working immigrants, and how she wants to make the US a place safe for people like her (I believe those kinds of appeals to personal experience win elections, consultants might think they’re cringe).

But she had to raise $8 million, so instead she took the advice of DCCC-approved consultants. Instead of leveraging her life history, she ran away from it. Instead of being a genuine person, she spends 20 minutes with Kyle Clark spouting the most uninspiring, lame justifications for stupid actions that I’ve heard in a long time. There’s some kind of deep moral failing in someone who doesn’t have the inner strength to build an image and campaign that’s uniquely her own. Clark sensed that, dug in deep, and this interview should end her campaign.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

There is another option besides voting "Yes" or "No" on messaging bills, and that is simply to vote "Present". Democrats should use that option more often.

Avatar

Joe is Wypoxic1 year ago

Might have said this before but I was made first wave "Red to Blue" in '08 by the DCCC running in WY. One prereq was that I use their preferred DC consultants (after I had almost pulled of the biggest upset in the country in'06 using only local media/mail/polling firms). I ended up firing 2 of the 3 DC consultants pretty early on - they had no interest in the actual dynamics of my specific race - only wanted to put my race on their resume (I had my 15 minutes of Dem fame as THE hot race back then). I'll take candidate and local firm authenticity over DC consultants every time...

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

She lost her seat to a Republican in a Republican wave election.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

Yes, and someone is going to win it back in 2026. But, I'm afraid it won't be her.

Avatar

Tam R1 year ago

We lost good people who voted for the Assault Weapons Ban and the ACA. Being a member of the House from a swing district is tough which is why leadership are usually from very safe districts.

Avatar

Kay W.1 year ago

Such a sad story! What she discovered is people can sniff out a phony. She should have stuck with what she is - an old school liberal. She may have still lost! The risk/reward analysis of this is all fucked up.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I don't generally believe that "when you're explaining, you're losing" because sometimes the job of a politician is to explain, but jeez Louise this interview was explaining to the point of absolutely chewing marbles as r po put it below.

Avatar

r po1 year ago

And... she did exactly what Mateo Church rakes in the money advising. And lost.

Let's see what we have here. A daughter who repudiates her parents and her own lived experience, and gives lip support to those who would make all of them suffer for it. And then chews marbles about how smart about it she is.

She's saying that the people who voted for her were fools.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

She has a good challenger, Manny Rutinel, who has 50 endorsements so far (which is something that Kyle Clark pushed in the interview -- Caraveo has zero endorsements.) So I think the die is cast on this one, but we'll see.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

With the depression, was she being erratic and mean to her staff? Is that why she disclosed?

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

I hadn't seen this piece in the Sun when I wrote this post:

https://coloradosun.com/2025/05/01/yadira-caraveo-staff-mistreatment-allegations-colorado/

But I think it explains why she has no endorsements. That's clearly staff mistreatment if what they're saying is true.

Clark's interview was before this came out, I think. He didn't push hard on the depression, just her dumb votes.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

I am afraid to tell you that Manny is a Yale graduate and an economist. He is trying to use "I worked at McDonald's" to pretend he is connected to the people, but I am tired of all these Yale graduates (like the mayor of Denver.)

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

He also sold plasma to pay his family bills.

https://www.mannyforcolorado.com/meetmanny

Hopefully he'll learn a lesson from Caraveo's votes and at least vote against messaging bills, despite his Yale education.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I'll give Rutinel credit in that he sponsored and the House passed an actual affordable housing bill and not a "affordable for affluent white professionals" housing bill or any other Theil-sourced, libertarian bullshit that our political lightweight Great White Dope of a mayor (and other New Dem/New Liberalism extreme centrists like Petterson and Crow) support and everybody hates.

She ran essentially an R-Lite campaign and golly gee, people chose the real thing over her.

The district was deliberately drawn to be "competitive", and Dem consultants and the aforementioned extreme centrist types assume that means the only way Dems can be competitive is if they are R-Lite...and when we lose, they simply want to double down on that.

Her interview with Clark displays that mindset in spades.

Avatar

Sepideh M1 year ago

I have not seen a lot of affordable housing anything in Colorado that has been meaningful. The invisible hand of the market is slapping some of those high housing prices, where prices are what they were two years ago.

House pricing was not strictly due to zoning. It was not strictly due to large REITs buying all the housing. Some of both things went on.

The "affordable housing" where you can't collect on gains while your neighbor's house gains like stocks wasn't working. The "affordable housing" with a crappy HOA where your dues are $600 a month wasn't working.

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

To be honest, Rutinel's bill isn't "meaningful" in the sense it has any widespread impact.

It's the fact he's not pushing the same crap that some of the Libertarians in Trench Coats on the other blog pushed nonstop for years and has absolutely torched Denver (and other cities). Any Dem in CO who doesn't buy into that bullshit is worth a second look as I've seen it play out (and push back against it) here since I moved back.

Also too, candidates and how they candidate matter. I don't have a good feel for how dynamic Rutinel is when compared to Caraveo, it could be the difference.

But I also agree with MM's "drive a car into a ditch" theory of current electoral politics. If things continue as bad as they are, this "competitive" district will turn to a (D) in 2028 to help get the car outta the ditch.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor1 year ago

The Colorado Sun "Sun Up" podcast on rent, and in Denver at least, apartment rents are coming down due to vacancies. They overbuilt luxury apartments with high rent an they're having to lower them in order to fill those units. What I've seen in the rental development market is that developers/property managers don't want to rent at lower rates because they will screw up their financing. Apparently this is changing. Here's the story:

https://coloradosun.com/2025/04/26/apartment-rents-denver-falling/

Avatar

Scott H1 year ago

I'd read that piece and others.

People are snorting when the headlines scream RENTS DROPPING, then you dig into the material and see that rents dropped $56, from the mid-$1800s to the low $1800s, snore. And the piece goes into great detail about the overall rent picture and that the drops are for the new builds nobody's moving into, not the older ones where rents continue to rise.

As we've discussed offline, 'loan covenants' drive much of rental rates. The vacancy rates are also problematic because all the data comes from the landlords and they typically aren't every accurate about posting negative numbers.

Last year with incredible candor, Denver's apartment lobby group said that they had 23K vacancies at the time with 48K more coming online within 3 years.

Finally, the numbers also reflect that fact and that the actual City of Denver is losing population. We attract young whites like nobody's business but they all leave when Liam and Emma are born.

Avatar

tam1MI 1 year ago

I'll give Rutinel credit in that he sponsored and the House passed an actual affordable housing bill and not a "affordable for affluent white professionals" housing bill or any other Theil-sourced, libertarian bullshit that our political lightweight Great White Dope of a mayor (and other New Dem/New Liberalism extreme centrists like Petterson and Crow) support and everybody hates.

I have heard you mention this many times and am genuinely confused as to what it means. Could you describe what these bad policies are and why they are bad?