Let’s start with England. I’m certainly no optimist, but I also don’t want to be a doomer. It’s a fine line, but looking at the current state of the Democratic Party, and also looking at the sorry state of the Labour Party in the UK, a possible outline of how the institutional Democratic Party could squander a mandate in 2028 is pretty obvious. Former LGM front-pager and sometime podcast guest Dave Brockington explains it in the latest LGM podcast.

I’m not an expert in British politics, but it’s clear that Keir Starmer is uncommonly politically ungifted, and Labour has done very little to materially affect the life of everyday Brits. Starmer came to power with a huge parliamentary majority, but was all on razor-thin wins for Labour, with around 34% of the votes cast. So, a mandate of sorts — certainly in the parliamentary system, they could have done whatever they wanted. But the real issue is that Labour did some incredibly unpopular things in the guise of stabilizing the Pound. Specifically, one of their first moves was to get rid of a Winter heating allowance payment for older Britons. Then, as far as I can tell, they’ve done very little that’s bold or notable, and now they’re in danger of losing to the right-wing Reform Party.

Again, not a British politics expert, but Starmer and Labour inherited a political situation were things were never going to be great — Brexit fucked the economy and made a whole lot of the day-to-day life in Britain harder and more expensive. The key point is that they had power to make change, and instead they reverted back to a combination of taking benefits away from ordinary people and incrementalism.

A deeply sclerotic center-left party that gets power after the previous party has done something dumb, in an environment where voters are intensely dissatisfied and hoping for change, yet does very little because they’ve been habituated to doing very little. I’m concerned that this is where the Democratic Party is headed. Anyway, if you know something about British politics, or if you listen to the podcast, and have a different opinion, I’d love to hear it.

Let’s move on to Canada. TBone sent in a piece from Press Progress on Canadian Ambassador Pete Hoekstra’s role in a scandal surrounding the Alberta separatist movement. That movement’s goal is to pass a referendum requiring Alberta to separate from Canada (and probably become the 51st state, eh).

Alberta is the most conservative province in Canada, and Conservative Alberta Premier Danielle Smith notoriously flirts with being “Maple MAGA”. Smith is officially against separation, but her government has consistently worked to make it easier for the petition to succeed. The Conservatives in Canada took a real shellacking in the election that resulted in Mark Carney becoming the Prime Minister, and Smith is apparently trying to get the separatists to support her in Alberta, despite separatism polling around 70/30 against in her province. The most recent news on the separatist petition is that a judge threw it out on the grounds that it violates the treaty rights of Indigenous Persons.

A group called the Centurion Project are supporting the separatist referendum, and the application they wrote exposed the private data of Albertans. For example, you could type in someone’s name and get their address, which is terrible, for example for women who are hiding from their domestic abusers. Elections Canada, where the database apparently originated, embedded fake names in the data so they could trace it if a leak occurred, and they’re in an active investigation doing just that. The Centurion app has been taken down based on a court order. Apparently, Centurion got the data from the Republican Party of Canada, a pro-separatist party, and they aren’t cooperating with the investigation.

The Hoekstra connection runs through an app called 10xVotes:

❝

The app, which [Centurion Leader] Parker described as the “10x slash the Centurion Project app,” targets low-engagement voters who may lean one way or another politically, but don’t reliably show up to vote. The app attempts to solve this problem by asking supporters to use their database to identify 10 politically-aligned friends, family or neighbours who can be pressured into showing up to vote.

First rolled out during the 2024 US presidential election, its backers tout 10xVotes as the secret weapon that helped deliver Michigan’s 15 electoral college votes to Donald Trump. Michigan Republicans are currently holding state-wide information sessions about 10xVotes in hopes that the technology will help send right-wing candidates to congress after this fall’s midterm elections.

A version of 10xVotes’ Michigan app reviewed by PressProgress has a substantially similar interface and functionalities as the Centurion Project’s app in Alberta.

[…]

Prior to being appointed ambassador to Canada, Hoekstra served as the chair of the Michigan Republican Party and was one of 10xVotes’ most vocal public backers.

During multiple 2024 rallies alongside Trump and his running mate JD Vance, Hoekstra explicitly called on crowds of Trump supporters to download the 10xVotes app in order to identify friends and family members to assist Trump’s ‘get out the vote’ efforts.

Press Progress via TBone

Hoekstra has no clear business relationship with 10xVotes, but it sure isn’t a good look for our Ambassador to Canada. Hoekstra is unpopular in Canada because he’s caustic, abrasive and generally an asshole, as well as clearly a Trumper.

Like Mexico’s US Ambassador “CIA Ron Johnson,” Hoekstra is another untrustworthy Trump appointee who’s helping to ruin a historically good relationship with one of our closest neighbors and allies.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 6 months ago(edited)

I’m spamming this post TBone style! ;)

But I can’t let it pass without pointing out that New Labour came into being because Tony Blair was so enamored with Bill Clinton’s Third Way politics.

And here we are, sowing.

Avatar

Scott H6 months ago

And today's Dem party continues Clinton's neolib/trickle-down/3rd way direction.

And wonders why people are not voting for them.

Oh yeah, EvErYbOdY Is a rAcIsT AnD A SeXiSt.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

British politics is easier for me to follow when JPie tells it:

https://youtu.be/83IYfRzlYv8?si=2C6JxJJUOqU7UEb2

He has a memorable way with words that resonates with me. Your mileage may vary!

Avatar
Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

I hope we're not saying this ourselves if we win in 2028:

https://youtu.be/9QnzfbIFVFg?si=8pZAYdpfu8saIjun

Avatar

C P6 months ago

TBone sent in a piece from Press Progress on Canadian Ambassador Pete Hoekstra’s role in a scandal surrounding the Alberta separatist movement. That movement’s goal is to pass a referendum requiring Alberta to separate from Canada (and probably become the 51st state, eh).

Not to digress too far, but it's remarkable how many right-wingers feel completely comfortable dropping even the pretense of classic patriotism. Trump goes on national television and asks Russia in front of millions of viewers to interfere in an election for him and not only does his approval among Republicans not go down, Putin's approval goes up. Far right parties in multiple former Russian colonies embrace Putin in their battle against liberalization and largely keep the loyalties of their bases. And Canadian right-wingers in Alberta respond to an actual threat of invasion from their southern neighbor by... joining an anti-Canadian secessionist movement transparently funded and supported by said invader.

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 6 months ago

I think they are accustomed to defining patriotism because almost all suspicion/accusation of anti-patriotism originates with them. For example, why could only Nixon go to China? For all the “both sides” nonsense, where is the equivalent of “Obama wants the terrorists to win“?

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 6 months ago

Of course, rampant hypocrisy is a defining feature of Right-Wing Authoritarianism.

Avatar

C P6 months ago

The key point is that they had power to make change, and instead they reverted back to a combination of taking benefits away from ordinary people and incrementalism.

Can you elaborate on this? "Incrementalism" usually means the moment isn't being met but that at least some progress is being made - the ACA being a classic example. Has anything like this come out of the U.K. under Labour lately? I've only heard about the "taking benefits away from ordinary people" type shit.

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

This is where my lack of knowledge of the British political system comes up. Brockington said that they were being incrementalist, so I trust him, but you're right that I, too, haven't heard of anything good from Labour.

Avatar

C P6 months ago

Whenever I feel down on the Democrats, I look over at Labour and think "could be worse."

But you're right, Labour is a frighteningly plausible look at what the Democrats may look like in 2028 or even 2026. What gets sort of lost by progressives in the remembrance of Obama and Biden's disappointments is that some real progress got made under both their governments in economic issues, and establishment Dems today (the Consultocracy especially) REALLY want to make sure that it goes down as a tragic and radical fluke never to be attempted again.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

I'm gonna prognosticate that an app that can be used for "asking supporters to use their database to identify 10 politically-aligned friends, family or neighbours who can be pressured into showing up to vote" and actually lets users see who showed up after the election! can also be used to retaliate against anyone so identified.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

“Remember this — 10xVotes,” Hoekstra told a November 2, 2024 rally in Warren, Michigan. “It is an app that you can download, and in real-time, up-to-date data, it will tell you whether your friends and family have voted or not.”

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

Disgusting

"The councillor says he is also hearing from others whose safety and lives have been affected after the group, called the Centurion Project, publicly distributed a list naming nearly three million electors in Alberta and their addresses."

Avatar

mister mixAuthor6 months ago

Yep, exactly.

There are serious penalties for misuse of the election database, like $100K fine and 1 year in prison. I hope Canada is serious about prosecuting this.

Avatar

Marmot Pimpernel 6 months ago

There’s several such apps in use on the Left, and it’s been a major point of several canvassing efforts I’ve been in to remind people that whether you vote is public information.

But about the apps, I believe you already need to know a voter’s address before getting voting info—that’s the only new info available.

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

It's a kerfuffle here in PA, privacy rights being defended by Dems

https://statesunited.org/resources/private-voter-information-in-pennsylvania/

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago

The Rethug-led state Senate vs. the Dems everywhere else

"To protect Pennsylvania citizens’ privacy and voting rights, Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro, joined by pro bono co-counsel States United Democracy Center and Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP, filed a lawsuit and petitioned the court to block the subpoena.

The lawsuit argues that the Senate subpoena, if enforced, would violate millions of Pennsylvanians’ right to privacy guaranteed by the Pennsylvania Constitution and the Commonwealth’s laws."

Avatar

TBone Dinosaur6 months ago